🔗 Share this article

Transgender director Sam Feder's newest film "Heightened Scrutiny" presents a powerful dual viewpoint – both an personal profile of a prominent transgender activist and a critical analysis of journalistic coverage surrounding trans existence.

Judicial Struggle at the Supreme Court

This feature follows ACLU attorney Chase Strangio as he prepares for oral arguments in the significant highest court case the Skirmetti case. These proceedings took place in late 2024, with the judiciary eventually deciding in favor of the state's position, effectively enabling limitations on treatment for trans minors to remain in place across numerous US territories.

We produced Heightened Scrutiny in just 16 months, shared Feder during an interview. By contrast, my earlier film Disclosure took me five years, so this was very accelerated. Our goal was to generate dialogue so people would understand more about the case.

Human Story Amid Legal Battle

While Feder offers a thorough critique of how prominent news organizations have promoted transphobic rhetoric, the film's most valuable achievement may be its compelling portrayal of Strangio. Typically a measured attorney in public appearances, Strangio reveals his vulnerability throughout the film.

This represented a substantial challenge, to share parts of my life to a documentary crew that I had made efforts to keep personal, shared Strangio. Feder said he wanted future generations to know that we struggled, to see what was done in service of these struggles for our fundamental rights.

Diverse Perspectives in the Movement

To support Strangio's account, Feder includes numerous transgender voices, such as prominent leaders from activism and entertainment. The documentary also presents insights from cisgender supporters who analyze how respected publications have contributed to damaging reporting of trans individuals.

The perspective of transgender youth key to the court battle is shown through a impressive 12-year-old girl named Mila. Audiences initially witness her speaking out for her community at a school board meeting, with later moments showing her protesting for trans rights outside the highest court.

Personal Scenes Beyond the Legal Battle

The documentary also contains poignant moments where Feder steps outside the ongoing political battle, such as sequences of Strangio traveling in Italy and getting a tattoo featuring lines from activist Pauli Murray's poem "Prediction."

This body art scene is among my favorites in the movie, explained Strangio. Being tattooed is almost like a contemplative process for me, to be fully present in my body and to consider it as a vehicle for things that are significant to me.

Body Autonomy and Portrayal

The filmmaker's attention to carefully showing Strangio adding to his body art emphasizes that this documentary is primarily about trans physical selves – not just those of young people who face denial of their right to live authentically in their own bodies, but also the bodies of the various participants who are featured in the production.

I produce films with a message, and part of that is choosing people who are outstanding and articulate enough to hold the camera, shared Feder. Whenever people ask me what they should dress for an interview, my response is anything that makes you feel confident. That is essential to me – as trans people, we have difficulties so much with our appearance.

Impact and Hope

A key aspect that causes Feder's films stand out is his obvious talent for making his transgender interviewees feel comfortable, recognized and appreciated. This methodology creates genuine connection between Feder and Strangio, enabling the filmmaker to realize his aim of showing Strangio as a complete individual and providing a testament for coming generations of how resiliently he and others have fought for transgender rights.

I hope not people to end up in a situation of constant discouragement because of what the law is failing to provide us, explained Strangio. I aim to be in a practice of using the law to reduce harm, but not to turn it into some sort of channel for our liberatory aspirations. The government is not going to be the reflection through which we view ourselves. Our community are that mirror, and it's really important that we persist having that dialogue alongside dialogues about fighting back these regulations and procedures.

Heightened Scrutiny is currently accessible for online viewing during Trans Visibility Week and will receive a more extensive launch at a later date.